Excuse Me Juror #6, What Medications Are You On?
An interesting article on law.com recently discussed the issue of lawyers asking jurors about their medication use. With so much of the population on medication, is drug use something that should be questioned of potential jurors? If so, how far should questioning go? Do we ask a general question? Whether the use of medication will interfere with a juror's duties, or do we delve deeper into more specific questions about the person, their conditions, and their treatments? The article, by Julie Kay, offers pros and cons while raising issues likely to continue making headlines(juror falling asleep in murder trial, someone goes off their medications during trial...).
As an attorney-advocate there may be times when seeking this information makes sense for my client. As the lawyer for my client I have the duty the pursue what's in my clients best interests. Personally, however, I think when we start asking jurors to divulge what medication they're taking, we're crossing a finer line. We have to wonder if the jurors' themselves aren't thinking, "Who is actually on trial, here?" Of course there are going to be exceptions to every rule, but speaking from a policy perspective, I'd rather have privacy rights' invasions remain the limited exceptions and not become the standard rule.
